Connect with us




Zamfara State is one of the few states that are facing serious economic crises and poor strategic planning, implementation and management in terms of revenue and expenditure framework. Its budgeting system is most a times not reflecting to the actual wishes of the majority of its populace and it has also depended largely on mono-source of revenue which is monthly statutory allocation from the federation account. These fiscal and monetary crises have affected the state strategic development plans especially with the infrastructural deficit, absence of investment plans as well as realistic saving plans for the doom period. This is not to say the crises are not surmountable but the state really need realistic action plans and strong political will on the side of the leadership to explore strategic options to save the state from eminent collapse. To discuss these viable strategies required for the state to change the narratives, an editor with the Thunder Blowers Nuhu Adamu Muhaamd has filed an extract from an interview with a World Bank scholar and economic policy analyst in person of Alh. Nasiru Kado Yahaya (Lamidon Gusau) on this and many issues.

What is your assessment of the economic planning of the state twenty three years after it was created?

I will like to say that the journey has been on and that some giant strides were made towards developing our fiscal and monetary policies. However, we are actually not where we are supposed to be. Our journey is characterized by what we termed in development economics as immiserising growth which implies growing at a miserable rate. A kind of growth that is characterized by one step forward and two steps backward.

 Why do we usually experience this kind of growth?

This could be attributed to lack of capacity that exist at the inception stage of planning right from the Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDA`s). I could remember during the military days, Zamfara used to be one of the few states with vibrant budgetary framework. In those days, we used to go to Abuja for budget defense, other states are being asked to understudy how we fashion out our budget. This is to tell you that, the framework used by the state in budgeting is superb but the capacity gap at the MDA`s in terms of planning the budget proposals ranging from conducting needs assessment, feasibility and viability studies and costing of projects in terms of bills of quantity up to sustainability analysis is lacking. This formed the basis upon which strategic development plans are developed. I challenge you to visit any state Ministry, Department and agency to find out what the practice is now and you will find out that, these procedures are no longer obtainable now. This could be attributed to absence of requisite training and re-training on this all important assignment as in most cases, the people charged with the responsibility rely heavily on on-the-job experience.
Why do you think most State Governors always implement projects that are not appropriated? Is this because of poor planning or deliberate political attempt to disrespect the laws?

This question is very critical to the discussion especially with the current trend among some states in Nigeria. It is a common logic that, one needs to plan if he really needs to succeed. Governors giving approvals running into hundreds of millions and sometimes into billions of Naira and politicians influencing projects execution outside the budget is indeed a bad precedence. There is approval threshold for a governor that do not exceed N250M and any approval of such will have to be deliberated and resolved at the Executive Council meeting before approval is granted. Once this provision is violated it could lead to an impeachment of a sitting governor. This is guided by the provision of financial regulation. 

This kind of practice is what is leading the state into fiscal deficit as a result of too much emphasis that is given to expenditure aspect of the budget at the detriment or expense of revenue.

It is not bad for a Governor or a politician to conceive a project idea for the benefit of people. A state cannot be governed up-head. That is why we have budgets and strategic planning documents. 

What impact do you think a sound economic planning and good governance could have on the people of Zamfara.

There is no doubt, with a sound economic planning and good governance, the sky will be the limit for Zamfara State because they are some of the internationally accepted best practices that move the economy forward. I will give you an example. If we have good electricity in Zamfara, you and I will not need a generator. If you have a sound education system in Zamfara, you and I will not take our children to private schools. If we have good health care system in Zamfara, you and I will not go to private hospitals or seek medical attention in private hospitals. If we have pipe-borne water in Zamfara, you and I will not need to drill borehole in our houses. The list is endless and these things constitute a burden on our meager resource and the result on you and I is that we end up subsidizing the inefficiency of government in terms of providing the basic amenities that make life worth living.  

There has been a growing concern about poor performance of Zamfara State in terms of Internally Generated Revenue with a bad tradition that the state derive N3B annually. Where do you think the problem lies.?

The issue of non performance could be connected to leakages of non remittance and corruption that allegedly abound in the revenue generation drive of the state. We have revenue generating agencies in Zamfara that makes proposals on revenue to be achieved in a given fiscal year and if you take the budget document you will find out that we have in the revenue (8) categories of IGR sub-heads ranging from taxes, fines and fees, licences, reimbursement, rent on government properties, miscellaneous and what have you. Out of this, only taxes perform up to 70-80% due to component of PAYE that is classified under it. The bulk of the N3B you are talking about come in as PAYE which is a statutory deduction from the salary of civil servants. The 9th revenue sub-head is statutory allocation that comes from the Federation Account. One of the obligations of the State Government once statutory allocation is received is payment of salaries of civil servant. So, unless the state government received its statutory allocation, it cannot pay salaries and derive PAYE. Yet the State Board of Internal Revenue classified PAYE under the revenue it generated and charge certain percentage as retention and share it among its staff even when they did not make any effort in its generation. By implication, once there is problem with statutory allocation, the state will be at stand still.
What in your opinion is the way out of this mess?.

The way out is to block these leakages. Remove the PAYE component from the sub-heads of Board of Internal revenue, review the existing revenue sub-heads and explore other ways and means of revenue generation.

How do you think the state government shall go about this your recommended ideas?

One of the ways you can block the leakages is by introducing a revenue and expenditure software developed by System specs called Remita and replicate the policy of the federal Government on Treasury Single Account so that anything that will come into the coppers of government can be viewed under one single account. Under this platform, anything coming into government will have to pass through the process of generating Remita Retrieval Reference Number, obtaining payment advice and receipt from the same platform and any payment by the state government can be made using the batching system under the same platform instead of paying revenues over-the-counter with or without receipt by the revenue generating agencies. This way, revenues and expenditure of government can be tracked easily. 

Budgeting system has been a source of concern to many stakeholders especially it was alleged that the way the budget is formulated is not appropriately responding to the real needs of the people and that, the system always target the expenditure and neglect the revenue component. What is your take on this?,

Well, I will like to refer you to the Financial Programming Model that International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank use in turning-around the economies of developing countries particularly those that found themselves in financial crisis. This model was developed by a renowned Economist called Polak and it can be used by state governments. The model is very transparent, encourages disclosure, centered around income/revenue accounting and conforms with the standards of International Public Sector Accounting System(IPSAS) and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

The System view National Income/State Revenues on one side of the equation and expenditure on the other side. Under the expenditure component, it emphasizes setting aside part of the income of government for activities like, rcurrent expenditure which include personnel and overhead cost, capital expenditure and investments in revenue generating ventures and savings to take care of unforeseen eventualities.

It will surprise you to note that if Statutory allocation is to be considered, Zamfara is richer than Ghana if Aids, donation, Loans and Grants are excluded from it`s realistic inflows. We did a comparative analysis of the budgets of Ghana, Sierra leonne, Liberia, the Gambia and Zamfara State in University of Ghana (Legon) with Professor Cletus Dordunoo (a Ghananian) in 2008 and we deliberately left out Nigeria and used Zamfara as a case study. Ghana is classified as one of the Highly Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) and the reports from the classification is what qualified them for Grants, donation, loans and Aid from developed countries.

What makes them different is that they are using this Financial Programming Model 100% and their IGR is capable of accommodating their recurrent expenditure. They channel the bulk of their inflows on investment and setting aside certain percentage as savings. As at the time the comparative analysis was done, the Government of Ghana has a Six (6) month import duty cover that was set aside as savings.

There has been concern about the manner at which the successive and current governments are securing loans from the local Banks in the name of project execution. Based on analysis, some of the projects are not likely the propriety of the people. How can we overcome this burden of loans and is it not possible to run a Government without loans?

It is actually very possible to run a government without securing loan even though, there is provision in the budget that allows governments in Nigeria to secure loans.

If you look at the budget of Zamfara State under the sources of revenue, you will find out that apart from Statutory allocation, grants, IGR, External loans to finance capital project, matching contribution to international NGO`s and VAT. There is also provision for internal loans.

Internal loan is allowed where the resources available to run a government is not available to take care of need of urgent importance. For example, where statutory allocation is delayed due to one reason or the other, the state may decide to take a commercial bank loan to off-set the salary of civil servants.

Problem arises when State Governments secure commercial Bank loans for long-term capital development projects due largely to the fact that commercial Bank loans are short term loans and they use a monetization schedule and charge interest on daily basis.

With the current situation in Zamfara, the best option is to restructure the short term loan liabilities into long term. This can be done by appointing a financial advisor that will serve as an intermediary between the state government and the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC). The financial advisor is a registered entity registered and recognized by SEC to package short term liabilities into long term. This way, a loan that is repayable over a period of one year can be spread over a period of 5-10 years and this can release more funds to execute other projects of government that would otherwise be used in settlement on short term loans.

In addition to that, the State may decide to float bonds if there is need for its capital development projects. There are varieties of bonds that the state government can tap into depending on the need and circumstances. One of them is SUKUK which is an Islamic way of financing and there are the conventional bonds too.

What is your view on State and Local Government Joint Account?.

Nigerian democracy operate under fiscal federalism which recognizes the three tiers of Governments Federal, States and Local Governments. Again under fiscal federalism, there are certain categories of taxes that belong to the respective level of governments. There is a provision in the Constitution that allow Governors to operate State/Local Government accounts. However, that provision is detrimental to the development of local governments. Imposing the same provision on to operate Federal/State joint account could simply put the economy of Nigeria into comatose situation the same way it grounded local governments. However, one cannot rule out political underpinning behind the motive of strangulating the local government chairmen so that they dance to the tune of the state governments. But I have a strong believe that a N100M spent in a given local government could have a trickle-down effect that could re-invigorate the economy of that local government.  
What advise will you give to government with a view to changing the narrative as it relate to economic planning and development of the state?.

Well, Alhamdulillahi, Zamfara State is blessed with professionals from diverse field of human endeavor that can serve as an engine room to move the economy forward, what is required is to engage them and to go back to drawing board. Let them come up with a blue print that will guide the development of the state. These, coupled with good governance and strategic development plan can be the road map for overcoming the development challenges and launching a new Zamfara that will be a shining example among its peers.       

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Daily News




The Senator representing Zamfara North Sahabi Alh Yau has inaugurate his 2023 campaign at Kaura Namoda local government area, the headquarters of the Senatorial zone.

The campaign inauguration was attended by hundreds of party supporters and well-wishers who joined the campaign rally with jubilation.

The Senator who expressed satisfaction with the effort he has put in place so far in delivering to his 2019 campaign promises assured that if provided the opportunity again, he will do more to consolidate from what he has done and ensure that more federal opportunities are brought to the door steps of his constituents.

He took time to make a review of his stewardship and thanked his constituents for given him the opportunity to represent them at the Nigeria’s upper chamber.

On the APC Presidential candidature, Sen. Yau in insisted that, Tinubu and Shetima Presidential candidature is the best option for Nigeria especially with the effort put in place by the Buhari led administration and why the gesture need to be sustained.

He urged people of his constituency to massively vote for Tunubu and Shatima as well as all the APC candidates across the board.

AFormer Governor Mahmuda Shinkafi, former Sen. Tijjani Yahaya and a host of other prominent personalities from the Zone attended the campaign Flag off.

Continue Reading

Daily News






Yusuf Idris Gusau


This is no doubt the best of times for the main opposition Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) in Zamfara State.

The party and its many candidates deserve the sympathy of all for the current situation it finds itself in.

Having lost all hopes of making any impact in the forthcoming general elections, it has resorted to untoward means, behaving like a bull in a china shop, destroying anything and everything in its way.

But how can a party of PDP’s standing, which has been in power at some points for many years and its candidates behave like deranged women whose kids have suddenly gone missing?

In this moment of madness, there should be a sane member within the lot who could rein them in; a rallying figure who could calm the fraying nerves.

But when a ranking member of one of the country’s highest law making body, the House of Representatives, Suleiman Abubakar Gummi’s joined the fray, it then becomes obvious that the situation is irredeemable.

The party, as it were, is doomed and at a dire point of no return.

The honourable member of the House of Representatives has swelled the number of the PDP’s attack dogs whose targets include the ruling party and the state chief executive, Governor Bello Mohammed Matawalle.

In a press statement he recently signed on behalf of “PDP candidates” titled “On critical national alert” Gummi went the “dishonourable” path by throwing decorum to the wind and lunched viral attacks on person and personality of Governor Matawalle with no iota of respect for his seat as the father of the state.

In doing so he deployed uncouth, crude and abusive language symptomatic of those low level maniacs unleashed at every opportunity as dogs of war.

But why will anyone be surprised at the action of this charlatan who forgot that his behavior could rob off on the integrity of the lower chamber he represents and taint the reputation of his colleagues in that reputable and respected institution? He is PDP member in the state after all and their stock in trade is to cause breach of peace in the state.

In the said press statement, Gummi went a rigmarole quoting the respected late social crusader, Martins Luther King and dancing around in circle.

From all his outing and vituperations, the only take away was the supposed arrest on Monday, November 28, of the party’s candidate for Zamfara central senatorial district, Alhaji Ikira Aliyu Bilbis by the police on charges of vandalism, which he claimed were trumped up.

In trying to elicit public sympathy to himself and co-travelers, he lumped the current issue with the earlier arrest of the Nigeria Union of Journalists chairman in the state but as usual, his effort failed to invoke the emotion and public outcry he had envisaged.

But let us even give him the benefit of the doubt and interrogate the issues his outing threw up. He has informed the public why Bilbis was arrested, but said the charges were “trumped up”. Really?

How did Gummi who is a lawmaker come about such a position over an issue that is before a court of law? Why is he in a hurry to clear the accused even before the court adjudicate on the matter.

The police even from Gummi’s statement did the needful by arresting Bilbis. They (police) did not hold him or keep him for long in their cell but charged him to court after their investigation.

The onus is therefore on the accused to exonerate and clear himself of the allegations.

The court even went ahead to grant him bail as Gummi testified in his statement. So why is it anybody’s fault if the accused failed to meet the bail condition? And because his associate failed to meet the stipulated condition to effect his release, Gummi is now accusing the judge and police of being tools in the hands of Matawalle in his alleged witch hunt of the opposition.

If a sitting governor is desirous in tackling an opponent who is clearly linked with a crime it would have been easy to clamp such person in police custody and claim that investigation is still ongoing as has been the case everywhere.

However, in this case, the police did not waste anytime in charging the accused to court where he is expected to defend himself. The court and its presiding judge should be commended for the expressway it granted the accused bail instead of being needlessly vilified like Gummi is doing.

His allegation that Matawalle was trying to muzzle the main opposition to whittle down their power and influence in the forthcoming elections is laughable because the PDP is not in reckoning and not a threat to APC in anyway.

He even went ahead to list those he thinks Matawalle will go after including the party’s governorship candidate, Lawal Dauda Dare. Waoo! Is this not absurd? Is Lawal Dare even in contention for the governorship race with all the court cases dangling over his head?

The so called governorship is still traumatized over his defeat at the federal high court, which nullified the primary that produced him and recently, the Appeal court.

It is fundamental to note that his ordeals were from his own very party and has nothing to do with Governor Matawalle. So it’s absurd to blame others for PDP’s misfortune and allege that anyone would hunt it’s candidates whose political future are uncertain.

And resorting to violence as a means to an end like the party and its members have been doing could only heighten the already tensed atmosphere which Matawalle has been working round-the -clock to manage.

The billboard saga wasn’t the only violent imprints the party has left on its route to 2023, a rally at its governorship candidate’s home had led to lost of Iives even as many were wounded. It’s sad that Gumi left out such important development from his statement.

As per the NUJ chairman which Gummi tried unsuccessfully to lump Bilbis case with to draw inspiration, he should have done the needful by telling the public the background of the affected person and the circumstances leading to such state of affairs to enable them appreciate and interrogate the issue based on its merit.

It’s imperative that Gummi calls a press conference or issue another statement to shedlight on the matter.

Having come from an honourable family, one would have thought Gumi will keep the legacy of the parental training we thought he received, unfortunately, even if he had such grooming as he was growing up, elements of bad politics and the fear of losing in the upcoming 2023 general elections have infuriated to throw away his sensibilities and turn disrespectful, dishonourable and regardless.

Certainly, with the overwhelming wind of mass support and mass mobilization going on in the APC, the likes of Gumi will not even be noticed when the electorate cast their votes to bring in APC at all levels in the coming elections.

As it were, rep Gummi achieved nothing by his recent desperate tactics. The PDP is doomed and irredeemable, and by 2023 the party will go into permanent extinction in Zamfara State.

Yusuf Idris Gusau
APC Publicity Secretary
Zamfara State
4th November, 2022

Continue Reading

Daily News




Former Governor of Zamfara State Abdulaziz Yari Abubakar has paid a condolence visit to Sen. Aliyu Magatakarda WAMMAKO over the demise of his wife.

Yari who described the deceased as God-fearing and devoted Muslim who has offered much serving humanity.

He urged the husband and indeed the family to take solace and consider the exit of the deceased as a call to eternity.

He prayed for God almighty to grant her Jannatul Firdausi and blessed what she has left behind.

Sen. Aliyu Wammako thanked the former Governor and his entourage for the condolence visit and prayed for God almighty to bless them accordingly.T

he former Governor has among his entourage Amb. Abdulrahaman Buba Kwacham among many other prominent personalities.

Continue Reading